Wednesday, June 19, 2019

The Crime of Being Ethnic: Japanese-American Concentration Camps During World War II


      Racism and hatred of immigrants has been a disease ever since the founding of the United States of America. Every immigrant group not originating from northwest Europe has suffered persecution from a small minority of ignorant citizens who think of themselves as the only true Americans. At the time of World War II, when Japan joined forces with the Axis powers of Germany and Italy, ethnic Japanese people gained first hand experience of the bigotry and hate that remains a chronic sickness in American society to this day.
     In the mid-nineteenth century, Meiji era Japan opened its doors to international trade and commerce in a bid to modernize their kingdom. An economic recession resulted and many Japanese people fled to America in search of work and economic opportunity. Most of them were peasants and farm laborers and the majority of them relocated to Hawaii and California. The Japanese immigrants were highly successful as agriculturalists and businessmen; farmers in California brought with them a new irrigation technique that made raising crops in difficult terrain much easier. They lived in quiet communities, spoke their own language, and practiced their own traditions. The white farm owners, many of which were less successful financially than the Japanese immigrants, were not happy about their presence on American soil.
     But the Japanese people remained. Then on December 7, 1941, Japan attacked Pearl Harbor in Hawaii and public sentiment turned from quiet resentment to open hatred. Fearing the possibility that the ethnic Japanese community would rise up to fight the USA on its own shores, possibly even building espionage networks to assist their Asian ancestors, became a fear of the American military. The government began a clandestine investigative committee and surveillance program to spy on the Japanese people and assess their level of loyalty to the United States. The committee found that they were deeply committed to their adopted nation with little to no sympathy for Japan. No anti-American propaganda was found in their communities, no pro-Japanese sentiment was heard of, and no spy networks were uncovered. Despite these positive findings, the military leaders insisted that Asian people were incapable of being true Americans and in the end their loyalty would go to the Japanese aggressors. Empirical evidence counted for nothing and racist hatred counted for everything. When it came to bigotry in politics, nothing could penetrate the thick fog of stupidity that clouded the vision of white Americans of that time.
     Franklin D. Roosevelt, long considered a champion of the poor and oppressed people of the USA, passed Executive Order 9066. The forced relocation and imprisonment of Japanese-Americans had begun. At first, zones of exclusion were drawn up. Territories in California, Oregon, Washington, and Arizona were demarcated on maps and Japanese people were informed that they were not, under any circumstances, allowed to leave those areas. Next a curfew that only applied to Asian people was put into effect, making it illegal for them to be outside their homes after dark. Then the military ordered all Japanese people to voluntarily bring whatever they could carry to the train stations; they were put on trains, and transported to redistribution centers in the desert northeast of Los Angeles. Finally they were transported to concentration camps located throughout the country; all of them were on the most inhospitable land in deserts, swamps, and Indian reservations. People who were thought to be potentially dangerous were sent to a high-security facility in Nevada.
     About sixty percent of the detainees were legally naturalized American citizens, mostly second and third generation people who were born in America. The government defined a Japanese-American as anyone being 1/16th Japanese, meaning having one great-great-grandparent of Japanese ancestry qualified the individual as being a potentially criminal ethnic minority. Elderly Japanese people as well as little children and the mentally disabled were deemed too dangerous to be allowed to live freely in American society. Ethnic Korean and Taiwanese people were also imprisoned because the Japanese had once conquered and colonized those respective nations, thereby making them potentially suspicious communities.
     Obviously, life in the internment camps was not easy. Most were located in high desert regions and the weather was hot and extreme in all of them. Surrounded by barbed wire fencing and monitored by guards armed with rifles, the barracks style houses were cramped and uncomfortable. Hastily constructed, they were little more than mosquito-infested wood boxes with tarpaper roofs. Families were kept together but 25 people were forced to sleep in houses that were made to hold only four. The beds were small cots and having so many people crowded together in small confined spaces led to outbreaks of illnesses and disease. Physically-fit adults were put to work doing manual labor to maintain the camps; they were paid 49 cents a day so that they could buy food from their captors to feed their hungry, malnourished families. Children and teenagers were forced to go to school where conventional curriculum was not taught; instead they were force-fed a steady stream of pro-American propaganda making the schools look uncomfortably like the communist re-education camps that were later to be set up in China and Vietnam. In the evening, men and women were forced to play baseball in an attempt to use the sport to make them more “American”.
     Some of the Japanese prisoners were given chances to prove their loyalty to their country, even though none of them had ever been anything but loyal. Questionnaires were distributed asking the people their opinion about how much they loved their country. Being worded in complicated and confusing ways, some people, especially those who were only moderately fluent in English, had trouble answering the questions correctly. Some, infuriated over their unnecessary imprisonment, sarcastically answered that they felt no admiration for the USA. Those who gave the wrong answers were shipped off to the high-risk concentration camp and eventually deported back to Japan. Many of them were old or uneducated people who did not understand what they were doing. But some young people who proved themselves to be intelligent were sent to progressive colleges on the east coast. Others were allowed to enlist in the army; these Japanese soldiers formed the 442nd Regimental Combat Team and went on to become some of the most decorated fighters for America in World War II since they assisted in the liberation of Dachau and were involved in a major operation to disrupt trains taking Jews to concentration camps in southern Germany.
     Very few prisoners tried to escape. The ones who did were either shot and killed or sent to the maximum security camp in Nevada.
     In 1944, World War II began to wind down. The Japanese-American prison camps were starting to closed. Most inmates were given $25 and a train ticket to return to their former homes. Most of them found their houses and possessions to be stolen or vandalized. Some of their property was burned or destroyed. Many American citizens treated them with hostility and contempt. A group of white supremacists petitioned the government to permanently remove all people of Asian descent from California. Otherwise Americans mostly remained silent on the issue for many years.
Then during the 1960s, young Japanese-American college students, inspired by the Civil Rights Movement, began agitating for reparations. Eventually both Presidents Gerald Ford and Jimmy Carter gave speeches condemning the internment camps. By the 1980s bills were passed through Congress with bipartisan support and the Civil Rights Act of 1988 was ratified by Ronald Reagan, giving $20,000 in reparation money to the survivors of the concentration camps. The disbursement of the money was overseen by both George H.W. Bush and Bill Clinton during their terms of office. Bush gave a speech proclaiming that the forced imprisonment of innocent ethnic minorities will never be allowed to happen again. As we pass into the 21st century, it is obvious that some Americans have refused to learned this historical lesson.
     Ultimately, reparation money and the building of monuments is fine. However, one has to ask if these gestures are really enough to heal the psychological damage that has been done to American society because of sadly idiotic mistakes made in the past.

References
Kelly, Edward H. and Harbison, Winifred A., The American Constitution: Its Origins and Development. W.W. Norton & Company, 1946.

Takaki, Ronald. A Different Mirror: A History of Multicultural America, Revised Edition. Back Bay Books, 2008.




No comments:

Post a Comment